All News

Top Italian Cardinal Throws Punch at New Civil Unions Law

By Andrea Gagliarducci

MRM Analysis: Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco makes several important points. Civil unions do put new forms of cohabitation on the same level of marriage, which has the effect of reinforcing that marriage is merely a committed relationship for the benefit and happiness of adults and separated from the rights and interests of children. He also rightly points out, that in addition to separating marriage from children, it also opens the door to the promotion of surrogacy which exploits poor women. More importantly, it opens the door for acceptance of the practice of surrogacy or donor conception which intentionally deprives children of the fundamental human right of knowing and being loved by their own mother, father or both. 

In the opening paragraph, the article refers to the Pope’s advocacy for “the natural family”. We don’t know if the Pope said it that way, but we recommend the use of the term “regular family,” to mean a family in which a man and woman make themselves irreplaceable to each other in marriage in preparation for having children. Not all married men and women have children, but every child has a mother and father and rebuilding a marriage culture must be based on promoting the human rights of children to be born and raised in a family with their own mother and father united in marriage (not just a mother and a father). This is Church teaching and we all have a corresponding duty to promote and defend those rights.

Vatican City, (CNA/EWTN News) — In a powerful speech Tuesday at the opening of the Italian bishops’ general assembly, Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco of Genoa decried the civil unions bill passed in the nation’s parliament last week, emphasizing that Pope Francis himself always advocates for the natural family.

The president of the Italian bishops’ conference peppered his May 17 speech with several lengthy quotes from the Roman Pontiff, and lamented that the Pope’s affirmations of the family are so often ignored in the mainstream.

The annual gathering of the Italian bishops is taking place May 16-19 on the topic of “renewal of the clergy.” Pope Francis had begun the assembly with a brief speech on the priesthood on Monday, followed by a closed door question-and-answer session with the bishops.

Second to the meeting with the pope, Cardinal Bagnasco’s address will set the tone for the bishops’ plenary, and his address focused on the civil unions bill which was passed May 11.

Championed by prime minister Matteo Renzi, the bill passed the Chamber of Deputies by a 369-193 vote of confidence for Renzi. It had already passed the Senate in February, after being watered down “to win the backing of conservative and Catholic senators,” according to The Guardian.

The bill affords couples in civil unions many of the rights of married couples, but its concession added to gain the support of some conservative senators is that parental rights are not granted to non-biological parents  in a civil union.

Senator Monica Cirinna, who sponsored the bill, said the watered down version which passed is a “hollow victory” and only “a first step,” according to the BBC.

Cardinal Bagnasco decried the new law and said that it “certifies an equivalence” between civil unions and marriage, even “though the law affirms that civil unions and marriage are different things.”

Such “differences are only tricks of terminology or juridical artifacts, which can be easily bypassed.”

According to Cardinal Bagnasco, the law is just an intermediate step “on the path to the final strike, which will eventually include the approval of surrogate motherhood, a practice that exploits women, taking advantage of their poverty.”

Surrogacy is currently illegal in Italy.

Cardinal Bagnasco underscored that people “want the parliament to be committed” to tackling real issues, such as unemployment and poverty. “What are public institutions doing,” he asked rhetorically, to give a long-term response to these issues.

He added that Catholic Relief Services in Italy had provided 12 million meals for the poor, and is in the frontlines assisting migrants who arrive, often illegally, on the nation’s shores.

“These are the real problems of the country, of the people. So, is is not understandable why (the Italian Parliament) spent so much emphasis and energy on causes that do not tackle these issues, and merely respond to ideological schemes,” the cardinal stressed.

Cardinal Bagnasco also noted Pope Francis’ repeated defences of the natural family.

He quoted from the pope’s joint declaration with Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill of Moscow, in which the bishops said that “the family is based on marriage, an act of freely given and faithful love between a man and a woman … We regret that other forms of cohabitation have been placed on the same level as this union, while the concept, consecrated in the biblical tradition, of paternity and maternity as the distinct vocation of man and woman in marriage is being banished from the public conscience.”

The cardinal also recalled that Pope Francis called the family “the foundation of coexistence and a remedy against social fragmentation” in his speech to the community of Varginha in Rio de Janeiro on July 25, 2013.

The pope had also, Cardinal Bagnasco continued, stressed at colloquium held Nov. 17, 2014, that “complementarity lies at the foundation of marriage and the family,” and for this reason “children have a right to grow up in a family with a father and a mother capable of creating a suitable environment for the child’s growth and emotional development.”

Cardinal Bagnasco also recalled that the Pope has so often underscored that gender ideology is “a mistake of the human mind” and doubted whether gender is  “an expression of frustration and resignation, which seeks to cancel out sexual difference because it no longer knows how to confront it.”

“It cannot be understood why these clear statements from Pope Francis, which the bishops often reiterate, are kept under silence, as if the Pope had never said or written them.”

The bishops of Italy, Cardinal Bagnasco said, “underscore the pope’s statements, so that they can turn into effective commitment.”